Critical Information Summary Case Study: Australian Phone & Internet

Critical Information Summary - Australian Phone & InternetThe new Critical Information Summary can be trickier to get right than you imagine.  Randomly, we picked a CIS from Australian Phone & Internet as a case study.  There’s a lot to like, but overall the CIS isn’t compliant with the Telecommunications Consumer Protections Code 2012.

We’ll explain why …

 Service description is jargon

Critical Information Summary - fixed wire The very first rule in the TCP Code is that:

A Supplier must communicate with Consumers in plain language.

Describing an ordinary home telephone service as a ‘fixed wire post-paid service only’ is far from plain language.  You could show this CIS to many ordinary people who would say, ‘Sorry, I’m not really up on all this new communications stuff.  I don’t know what a fixed wire post-paid service only would be.’

The detailed Critical Information Summary rules emphasise how important this is:

Language: use language to communicate its Offers (whether orally or in writing, including in the Supplier’s Advertising) which is suited to the intended audience


Clarity: provide information about its Offers in a comprehensible, clear and accurate manner, without exaggeration or omission of key information.

 Total plan cost is not stated

Critical Information Summary - no total cost There’s a minimum term contract but the total cost of the plan over that minimum term is not stated.  We have pointed out before that the Australian Consumer Law requirement that total plan cost must be stated applies to a Critical Information Summary just like any other advertising.  It’s quite a serious breach of the ACL to omit it.

It’s also a breach of the TCP Code, which requires that a telco must not:

advertise or promote a periodic price to be paid for a Telecommunications Product without also Prominently Displaying (but not necessarily as prominent as the periodic price) the “single price” as defined in the Competition and Consumer Act.

No statement of maximum early termination charge

Critical Information Summary - ETFThe TCP Code requires a Critical Information Summary to state ‘the maximum charge payable for early termination of the offer’.  The code doesn’t allow a CIS to state the method of calculation but not the actual maximum figure.

Other clauses in the code do direct a telco to state a certain figure and its method of calculation (see clause 5.2.4) or the figure or its method of calculation (see clause 6.8.1(d)).  So the code is well aware of the difference between a figure and its method of calculation.  There’s nothing to stop the CIS we’re studying from volunteering the method of calculation, but it must also state the maximum figure.

In passing, we’ve also explained why calculating early termination charges on the basis of the full balance of plan fees may be illegal.

A note about mobile calls

Critical Information SummaryThis doesn’t make the Critical Information Summary non-compliant but we note it in passing.

There’s often no way for a customer to know whether they are dialing a number of the Telstra mobile network, or another network.  That could result in a big bill shock with this plan.  We’d advise plenty of clear warning about that … long gone are the days when a customer could assume that ‘0418’ etc were always Telstra numbers.

Another comment:  No need to state cost of 2 minute call

Critical Information SummaryThis is another information comment:  There’s no need for the Critical Information Summary to state the cost of a 2 minute call to a mobile phone.  There’s nothing to stop a telco from including this information in a fixed line phone CIS, but it is not required by the TCP Code.

The TCP Code requires a CIS to state:

the cost (prior to any discounts being applied) of making a 2 minute Standard National Mobile Call (including flagfall where applicable

And a “Standard National Mobile Call” is defined as:

a mobile voice telephone call from a Supplier’s mobile service to another Supplier’s mobile service (off-net) during peak time where the calling and receiving parties are in Australia

So this requirement is never mandatory in a Critical Information Summary for a fixed line phone service.


The Critical Information Summary requirements can be tricky to get your head around.  That’s why we produced a one page visual guide that would have alerted the telco to each of the issues identified above.

[wp_eStore_fancy2 id=10]


About Peter Moon

A telco lawyer with a truckload of experience
This entry was posted in Backgrounders, Critical Information Summary and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.